Ending Shamshir Listing

[FenrisWolf]

Originally Posted by derek

Just to clarify,


What I started this thread I was just noting that a sword like this would not have sold for more than $350 just a year ago. Now it's not unusual to see items like this hit close to $1000. That's great for sellers (including me). Not so great for buyers (including me).

No one should read anything more into the reason I started this thread. I don't know why any responses were deleted.

-d

All it takes is one or two new collectors with deep pockets and not much knowledge to skew the sales on a specific item, especially if you have buyers who want to start collecting edged weapons but don't want to take the sort of plunge necessary to get involved with, say, high-end japanese swords. One can acquire beautiful, museum-quality yataghans for a fraction of the price one would pay for a comparable katana....

[Yannis]

I met an old collector lately. His is stockbroker. His opinion is that prices are gone very high last years because there is cash available (not in my pocket ). If something goes wrong with the market, he said, nobody will give a dollar for our fancy blades.

We agreed that collecting like investment is good profit but also high risk. It works only in shiny days and there is no umbrella for the rainy days. So, once again... CAVEAT EMPTOR

[Tim Simmons]

I am always puzzled at how fickle prices can be and how high some rather questionable pieces can go. Judgements of completeness, concepts of quality and rarity seem to have no relation some of the time. It does make me wonder how versed some of these buyers are, or do their hearts take over their eyes, minds and money. It can happen to us all .

[Rick]

I think one has to also remember that there is an emerging middle class in countries that never really had one before .
Some of these people will be collectors and are joining the consumer base for antique edged weapons; particularly from their own culture/s .

[ALEX]

Just my 2 cents: If we'll think of antique edged weapons as of any other category of antique, we'll realize that it WILL appreciate with time. Anything of good quality and old WILL increase in value, and there Always be a market for it. There are no exceptions, and there Always be money for an original, well preserved and of good quality item. Period:-)

Also, Ariel: I do not see any Turkish Ribbon pattern on this blade. It's quite undefined.

[Mark]

Spunjer and mavi1970: I refer you to the following paragraph in the "Posting Guidelines" sticky thread:

Discussion of auctions should never include editorial comments about the seller. Please take those discussions to private e-mail.

I also refer you to the following paragraphs in the same post, and the highlighted passages in particular:

9. VIKINGSWORD STAFF

The Vikingsword Staff is comprised of Site/Forum Administrators, Forum Moderators and Technical Advisors. Decisions made by Vikingsword Staff are not subject to public debate. Please utilize the board's Private Message function, or e-mail, if you wish to discuss a situation with a moderator.

Although this forum does not and cannot review the messages posted and is not responsible for the content of any of these messages, we at this forum reserve the right to delete any message for any or no reason whatsoever. You remain solely responsible for the content of your messages, and you agree to indemnify and hold harmless this forum, vBulletin, Jelsoft Enterprises, Ltd. (the makers of the bulletin board software), the forum administrators, Staff, moderators and their agents with respect to any claim based upon transmission of your message(s).

[Spunjer]

mark,


i see. i wasn't aware that my short and to the point response amounts to an editorial comment towards the seller. i was, in my whole heart, thought that instead of guessing whether the the specific sword was indeed a rework or not and in the process gives a fellow member a bad reputation of selling such a sword, why not ask the seller himself in order to clarify what really IS going on? i'm referring to this response, btw, just to be on the same sheet:

Hey I am no expert in this area but I spotted that it had been reworked right off the bat.

my thinking is, it's easy to guess, but much harder to confront the person himself or herself, reason why rumors is so prevalent in our society.

as for the rest of your response, mark, it never was my intention on debating your decision in regards to removing my post; again, there was no agenda behind when i ask why my post was deleted.

[spiral]

Originally Posted by ALEX

Just my 2 cents: If we'll think of antique edged weapons as of any other category of antique, we'll realize that it WILL appreciate with time. Anything of good quality and old WILL increase in value, and there Always be a market for it. There are no exceptions, and there Always be money for an original, well preserved and of good quality item. Period:-)
.

Commodes? Carving knives? Both probably worth considerably less than they did 100 years if one takes acount of inflation.

Spiral

[ALEX]

Originally Posted by spiral

Commodes? Carving knives? Both probably worth considerably less than they did 100 years if one takes acount of inflation.

Spiral

It ALL depends on "rarity factor". A plain old commode can be found abandoned on the sidewalk. On the other hand, I am sure that complete, original and rare commodes are sold for many thousands, even considering inflation. Just look at the antique catalogues. Can not argue about Carving knives though - you have a point