Sword 12/13 century or not?

[Will M]

I think it is unscientific to assume such swords found are automatically labelled fakes, it's like being guilty before proven innocent. I do suggest due diligence and proper testing by recognized professionals.
Yes there are obvious fakes however when it's not obvious it does not help to label anything as a fake. Anything is only fake if it's not authentic and is being represented as being so.
I do not believe that online digital photos alone can decide the authenticity of a sword. You need it in hand. People that have handled many of these particular swords would have a better take on this sword. Not many people have the experience due to the rarity and locations of such swords.
When I know something is a reproduction or fake I will point out the details.
If I don't know I will depend on professionals and testing if required.
Providing an opinion is good but requires backup, otherwise it's not useful to the poster of this sword.