Bowie knives

Rich · 12th February 2006, 10:51 AM

I've been collecting bowies (among other sharp pointy things) for
about 40 years. The "original" was basically a large butcher knife which
bears little resemblence to what people today think of as a bowie knife.
Certainly not an original design. I've a French hunting knife from circa
1790 that anyone would call a "bowie knife".

Rich

Spunjer · 12th February 2006, 01:49 PM

rich,

are you familiar with this type of knife (name, what era, etc.)? do you know what it's called?

Rich · 12th February 2006, 05:22 PM

You're not going to like my reply :-( but I believe this is a
total fake. It is a rework IMHO of a 1950-60's carving knife made
in India. I've seen dozens and dozens of knives exactly like this
with carved sheaths and handles and plainly marked made in India
or just India.

Rich

ariel · 12th February 2006, 06:02 PM

I do not think it is a "fake".
True, the construction looks just like these awful souvenir knives from India. However, the blade is very different and the quality of the woodwork and the bronze (brass? Always confuse them....) is quite good. The handle looks like Punal. I think somebody in the Philippines took the idea and reworked it from scratch.
The wood may be revealing.

Jim McDougall · 12th February 2006, 06:12 PM

Titus,
I have always considered the 'Bowie' knife to be about the closest thing to a real American 'ethnographic edged weapon' ! As noted by Rich, the term itself became colloquial for many forms of heavy bladed knives with clipped point by the mid 19th century, thus considered 'weapons' rather than simply 'hunting knives'. Ironically, probably the most prominant producers that capitalized on the use of the term 'Bowie knife' were those by Sheffield makers, in England! Later of course, German commercialism entered the field as well.

It would be difficult to really assert the true origins of the Bowie knife, as there is more than considerable folklore and speculation that has grown over the years. For those seriously interested, I think the best resouce on these knives and comprehensively all associated forms of these knives would be,
"The Bowie Knife' by Norm Flayderman (2004, ISBN 1-931464-12-X).
This book is magnificent! and well researched by one of the most well known and respected authorities on Americana. Fantastic book with amazingly photographed examples throughout.

Best regards,
Jim

Jim McDougall · 12th February 2006, 06:15 PM

Just noticed the excellent call by Ariel on the knife with U.S.A. on the scabbard!!! Nicely done Ariel, I very much agree that it is a punal!!!
Actually a pretty nice looking knife

Jim

Jim McDougall · 12th February 2006, 06:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich

I've been collecting bowies (among other sharp pointy things) for
about 40 years. The "original" was basically a large butcher knife which
bears little resemblence to what people today think of as a bowie knife.
Certainly not an original design. I've a French hunting knife from circa
1790 that anyone would call a "bowie knife".

Rich

I very much agree Rich. Actually the Bowie brothers, James and Rezin, were quite familiar with European style knife fighting, as they had considerable contact with this in thier dealings in Louisiana in somewhat controversial 'business'. The actual form of the knife is believed to have derived most likely from the 'Meditteranean' forms of knife carried by men from both France and especially Spain. The notching on the back of the blade suggests probably more Spanish influence however. Regardless, the deadly knife combat of the Spaniards as well as the French is well known.

Surprisingly the first use of the term 'Bowie' knife to describe a specific form was in a news item in 1835 (Flayderman, op.cit. p.22), actually the year before James Bowie achieved his immortal fame at the Alamo along with those other courageous defenders who died there.

Best regards,
Jim

Rich · 12th February 2006, 08:59 PM

Punal, maybe; althought I still think reworked India.
Fake? yes, in any case if it was sold or represented as an
old American "bowie" knife.

Rich

not2sharp · 13th February 2006, 04:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich

Punal, maybe; althought I still think reworked India.
Fake? yes, in any case if it was sold or represented as an
old American "bowie" knife.

Rich

I doubt that it is a fake or a reworked peice; nor, is it a bowie. This is probably a souvenir knife that was likely made in theater during WWII.

n2s

Lew · 13th February 2006, 12:15 PM

Hi Guys

I think this is a reworked older Indian knife circa WW2. The blade seems to be made from very thin stock where as older bowie knives where no less than 3/16" thick at the spine. Here is a pic of a 1890s or so bowie made in India which I believe these later knives were copied from.

Lew

Spunjer · 13th February 2006, 01:18 PM

Quote:

You're not going to like my reply :-( but I believe this is a
total fake. It is a rework IMHO of a 1950-60's carving knife made
in India. I've seen dozens and dozens of knives exactly like this
with carved sheaths and handles and plainly marked made in India
or just India.

it's ok rich, lol. this specific knife was sold on ebay awhile back (not to me) and the only reason i saved the picture was because the seller said it was a civil war knife, and the locking mechanism intrigues me. never saw anything like it. i was gonna post it awhile back and see if anyone recognizes it. i'm glad i procastinated...

Rich · 13th February 2006, 01:25 PM

Beautiful Arnacellum hunter. These are really nice, well made knives (I've two
of them; one exactly like this). While not "bowies" in the classical sense;
ie, too late and wrong countries; still really finely made knives. Flayderman
(if I recall) attributes to being made for English in India circa mid - late 1800's;
brought back to England and then to US circa turn 20th C. Quality certainly
nothing like the carved sheath India carving knives I was referring too.

Rich S

12th February 2006, 01:49 PM	#2
Spunjer Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Witness Protection Program Posts: 1,730	rich, are you familiar with this type of knife (name, what era, etc.)? do you know what it's called? Attached Images

13th February 2006, 12:15 PM	#10
Lew (deceased) Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: East Coast USA Posts: 3,191	Hi Guys I think this is a reworked older Indian knife circa WW2. The blade seems to be made from very thin stock where as older bowie knives where no less than 3/16" thick at the spine. Here is a pic of a 1890s or so bowie made in India which I believe these later knives were copied from. Lew Attached Images

12th February 2006, 10:51 AM	#1
Rich Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: comfortably at home, USA Posts: 432	I've been collecting bowies (among other sharp pointy things) for about 40 years. The "original" was basically a large butcher knife which bears little resemblence to what people today think of as a bowie knife. Certainly not an original design. I've a French hunting knife from circa 1790 that anyone would call a "bowie knife". Rich

12th February 2006, 05:22 PM	#3
Rich Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: comfortably at home, USA Posts: 432	You're not going to like my reply :-( but I believe this is a total fake. It is a rework IMHO of a 1950-60's carving knife made in India. I've seen dozens and dozens of knives exactly like this with carved sheaths and handles and plainly marked made in India or just India. Rich

12th February 2006, 06:02 PM	#4
ariel Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Ann Arbor, MI Posts: 5,503	I do not think it is a "fake". True, the construction looks just like these awful souvenir knives from India. However, the blade is very different and the quality of the woodwork and the bronze (brass? Always confuse them....) is quite good. The handle looks like Punal. I think somebody in the Philippines took the idea and reworked it from scratch. The wood may be revealing.

12th February 2006, 06:12 PM	#5
Jim McDougall Arms Historian Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Route 66 Posts: 10,616	Titus, I have always considered the 'Bowie' knife to be about the closest thing to a real American 'ethnographic edged weapon' ! As noted by Rich, the term itself became colloquial for many forms of heavy bladed knives with clipped point by the mid 19th century, thus considered 'weapons' rather than simply 'hunting knives'. Ironically, probably the most prominant producers that capitalized on the use of the term 'Bowie knife' were those by Sheffield makers, in England! Later of course, German commercialism entered the field as well. It would be difficult to really assert the true origins of the Bowie knife, as there is more than considerable folklore and speculation that has grown over the years. For those seriously interested, I think the best resouce on these knives and comprehensively all associated forms of these knives would be, "The Bowie Knife' by Norm Flayderman (2004, ISBN 1-931464-12-X). This book is magnificent! and well researched by one of the most well known and respected authorities on Americana. Fantastic book with amazingly photographed examples throughout. Best regards, Jim

12th February 2006, 06:15 PM	#6
Jim McDougall Arms Historian Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Route 66 Posts: 10,616	Just noticed the excellent call by Ariel on the knife with U.S.A. on the scabbard!!! Nicely done Ariel, I very much agree that it is a punal!!! Actually a pretty nice looking knife Jim

12th February 2006, 08:59 PM	#8
Rich Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: comfortably at home, USA Posts: 432	Punal, maybe; althought I still think reworked India. Fake? yes, in any case if it was sold or represented as an old American "bowie" knife. Rich

13th February 2006, 01:25 PM	#12
Rich Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: comfortably at home, USA Posts: 432	Beautiful Arnacellum hunter. These are really nice, well made knives (I've two of them; one exactly like this). While not "bowies" in the classical sense; ie, too late and wrong countries; still really finely made knives. Flayderman (if I recall) attributes to being made for English in India circa mid - late 1800's; brought back to England and then to US circa turn 20th C. Quality certainly nothing like the carved sheath India carving knives I was referring too. Rich S