mamluk khanjar ??

B.I · 13th July 2005, 06:02 PM

very interesting. i know the ottomans had a type of khanjar, which may have descended from this mamluk weapon, if it existed.
remember, you are taking one persons translation of a 15thC writing. david nicolle may have used the term 'khanjar' for want of a better term. maybe the weapon he was describing had no known name, and he used this term out of context. or maybe he did so with the ottoman dagger in mind and assumed they were describing a similar weapon.
just a thought.

13th July 2005, 06:02 PM	#5
B.I Member Join Date: Jan 2005 Posts: 485	very interesting. i know the ottomans had a type of khanjar, which may have descended from this mamluk weapon, if it existed. remember, you are taking one persons translation of a 15thC writing. david nicolle may have used the term 'khanjar' for want of a better term. maybe the weapon he was describing had no known name, and he used this term out of context. or maybe he did so with the ottoman dagger in mind and assumed they were describing a similar weapon. just a thought.