|
22nd November 2009, 02:58 PM | #1 | |
Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 235
|
Well Alan,
I cannot but to agree with the ideals you present - as you know already - but that is not the question, the question is, and I quote myself: Quote:
This means that the principle that this forum is all about the gathering and transfer of keris related knowledge is to be enforced ruthlessly. What I cannot see possible is to have a some sort of a middle ground. - It just does not work like that. Commercialism then either has to be banned completely or freed completely and let the public decide what is and is not acceptable. Everything in between is doomed to fail. The question basically is then what is the reason for the forums existence? When that is outlined on a clear and concise manner the rest is easy. There is no way that all opinions could be addressed satisfactorily as our motives for being here differ. A forum has to be something for somebody. It cannot be everything for everybody. The wider the audience wanted, the looser the rules have to be. The tighter the grip the smaller the audience that accepts such a firm control. I think it would be best to address what is the reason for this forums existence and then make decisions based on that regarding the acceptance or banning of commercial elements. I have nothing to add except reinstating that in my opinion there can be no middle ground. - Commercial elements are either OKīd 100% or banned 100%. Anything in between is doomed to fail as drawing the line would be extremely difficult and lead to complications on what it is and what is not OK . Thanks, J. |
|
22nd November 2009, 05:43 PM | #2 | |
Keris forum moderator
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Nova Scotia
Posts: 7,042
|
Quote:
Like Alan, i am here to share knowledge and learn from others. What i know (or think i know) i am always willing to quite freely share. What i do not know i am always willing to listen to and learn. This is the mission, i believe, of this forum, to freely exchange thoughts and knowledge about keris and the culture of keris. I personally have no intention, desire or inclination to ever run an appraisal-for-hire aspect of this site and i seriously doubt that any other knowledgeable members will be interested in such a undertaking either. Besides all of the afore mentioned reasons why there is also the extremely practical one that you simply cannot give a truly accurate appraisal of a keris without examining the item firsthand. Photos are just not good enough to make definitive judgments of certain aspects of keris. If someone else wants to try to set up an internet site that provides this service then i say more power to them. I would personally take any assessment coming from such a site with one huge grain of salt. I also must point out that the goal of this forum is not necessarily to fill the needs of the lowest common denominator of keris collectors in order to gain the largest membership possible. It is the free exchange of thoughts, ideas and knowledge of keris and keris culture between collectors of a like interest. It is to grow our understanding of the keris and the culture that supports it so that we might better grasp it's place in that society and in human history and to discuss what is happening in the world of crafting high-end art keris in present day. I do not see this as a place to appraise monetary value of keris, which in and of itself is both a tricky and highly subjective thing. So if you are a dealer whose sole purpose for being a member here is to present keris that are intended for sale then you are indeed in the wrong place. This does not mean that members who also sell keris are not welcome here. We have many who are regular, productive contributors who have never attempted to present keris for sale on this forum. And there are a few who have never even used the Swap Forum to sell an item other than to post a link to their sales site. They understand the purpose of this forum and show great respect for it and i think that in doing so they have also shown their high level of integrity and honesty as dealers, a very valuable commodity in my book. For some reason i trust a dealer more who isn't always trying to push their items on me like a sneaky used car salesman. Rick has presented 3 additional guidelines to address this issue which i fully support. I would also add that if you do try to sell something in Swap after the 30 day waiting period that it should be clear that you can in no way, shape or form provide a link in your sales thread to the previous discussion on the forum. In other words, you cannot use the comments of other forum members to promote the sale of your keris unless you receive express permission from every single person who participated in that thread. |
|
22nd November 2009, 07:08 PM | #3 | |
Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 235
|
Quote:
Do we want it or not, most people here are more or less continuously on the look out for new additions to their collections. It would be for the benefit of the unexperienced collector to have some sort of reference that the new addition that he is considering is not a lemon but as a worthy an addition as can be judged from two dimensional pictures on the www. Yes, for granted a wise collector buys the seller but given the nature of the keris it is many a times that even the most honest of sellers is selling something that he think is X only to find out (if it is found out) later that it actually was Y or Z. - Not all vendors have the grade and understanding of, say Mr. Maiseyīs. If I am buying a new addition to my watch collection and I am not 100% sure of what I am dealing with never mind who the seller, I will post pictures on the forums and ask for the opinion of the more seasoned collectors who are experts on the model in question. Yes. Watches are nothing like the keris for a myriad of reasons, but the risks in acquiring them on the internet are not very different from each other. Why cannot a collector ask for the opinion of a more seasoned collector outside the forum, well, of course there is nothing to stop him or her for doing that. Is it not how ever natural to ask something of this nature on the forum dedicated for the items in question? I understand that opening the door for something like this might bring along unwanted side effects. It might however also ignite the motivation for the beginning collectors to seek for a deeper understanding that is the norm of most postings. If we want this place to be a completely free zone of all having to do with commerce that is more than OK for me. I just voiced an alternative possibility, no biggie. Thanks, J Last edited by Jussi M.; 22nd November 2009 at 07:39 PM. |
|
22nd November 2009, 07:53 PM | #4 | |||
Keris forum moderator
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Nova Scotia
Posts: 7,042
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
22nd November 2009, 08:11 PM | #5 |
Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 235
|
Well David,
I donīt see any point in continuing this talk this anymore really? It is fruitless to try argument contra something that is cemented law. Thanks, J. |
22nd November 2009, 07:10 PM | #6 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,247
|
Hi David and Rick,
I think #1 and #2 and well-intentioned, and may well turn out to be draconian and unenforceable. As all of you know, I'm not a seller or a much of a collector, so I'll use myself as an example: Suppose I post new something here, and ask where it's from. Someone says, "Nice keris. I think it's from Bali." A week later, my fiancee finds out I bought it, and hits the roof, saying that we'd agreed to spend money on the house first, not on toys, and we don't have room for it anyway (this happens to be mostly true). I decide to sell it on eBay. "For sale, nice keris, probably from Bali. Starting bid US$40." I will be banned if I didn't get permission to quote whoever it was. Or I can lie and say it's an excellent keris from Java, US$200, and be okay??? And how does me having permission work, anyway? I have to email the moderator before I put up the item for sale? Or do I get banned first, and then have to defend myself by forwarding emails and hoping you believe that I didn't just write them myself? At the very least, I would suggest putting in the rules something about the moderators having sole discretion about what to do to offenders. I would be happier if there was a procedure in place for dealing with potential offenders too, but that is a lot of work. Last edited by fearn; 22nd November 2009 at 07:31 PM. |
22nd November 2009, 07:28 PM | #7 | |
Vikingsword Staff
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 6,267
|
Quote:
We can only try to control what happens in this forum and what happens to content use concerning this forum . You would not be banned . If you placed your hypothetical keris on ebay no one would ban you . If you wanted to use forum comments the rules apply ; you must first get permission . In the case of a simple 'nice Bali keris' no problems . If you were to post a link to the ebay auction in Swap before the 30 days were over I'd feel concern . Rick |
|
22nd November 2009, 07:33 PM | #8 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,247
|
Hi Rick,
I edited my comment while you were writing. Probably your post won't change, but check. Sorry about the cross-post, and feel free to delete this comment if you want. |
22nd November 2009, 08:11 PM | #9 | ||
Keris forum moderator
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Nova Scotia
Posts: 7,042
|
Quote:
I don't think you are completely understanding what Rick has suggested here. #1 is, of course, dependent upon the vigilance and cooperation of all our members. If you see someone using a quote you or someone else wrote on a thread to support the sale of their keris send us the prove of it. I know that i would not be happy if someone were using my assessment, given in the spirit of helping a collector better understand what his keris is, used as a sales pitch further down the line. Would you? The 30 day sales ban that Rick was suggesting was if you want to place the keris in our Swap Forum. We are not about to police the entire internet. It is not our place or intention. But as Rick stated, if you put it on eBay before the 30 days, don't post a link to the auction in the Swap Forum. Quote:
|
||
22nd November 2009, 08:12 PM | #10 | |
Vikingsword Staff
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 6,267
|
Quote:
|
|
22nd November 2009, 10:01 PM | #11 |
Member
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: The Netherlands
Posts: 2,221
|
Pfew !
Quite a bit of discussion going on here. I did not know my "Dha thread" and sale on the swap had so much effect (just kidding) But seriously, It is quite clear why this thread started. There are on occasion new members who only start threads for apprasion and than put them in the swap forum shortly after. I have seen them come, but also see them go... Maybe you could implement some system where you have to be an active member for a certain time before you are allowed to post items in the swap ? These seekers of fortune probably won't have time and energy to actively join his forum without generating sales. |
23rd November 2009, 12:20 AM | #12 | |
Keris forum moderator
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Nova Scotia
Posts: 7,042
|
Quote:
|
|
22nd November 2009, 10:52 PM | #13 |
Member
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 6,736
|
I really like the way this discussion has developed.
It's not quite the way I thought it might run when I started the thread, and I am a little disappointed that more people have not let us hear their opinions, but the opinions that have been given I personally, value. Fearn:- I'm sorry for my misunderstanding of your intent in respect of David's "nice keris" comment. I understood David's comment in one way, you understood it in another. It can be quite difficult to transfer meaning and intent clearly and concisely in writing, not infrequently we miss a message that in face to face conversation would be very clear. For this reason I feel that a few extra words at the outset can avoid the need for additional words later. I'd be the first to admit that I tend to overdo this approach a little, but it is much easier and faster to write than it is to think. I believe it was Mark Twain who apologised to friend :- " I'm sorry for writing such a long letter, but I didn't have time to write a short one." The points you have made have merit, but I do think that David and Rick have provided the answers that will address the concerns that some of us have in respect of misuse of this Forum. Jussi:- Yes, you've identified the exact question that needs clarification:- "The question basically is then what is the reason for the forums existence?" I think that Rick and David have now provided this clarification, and its pretty much as I understand it myself. But you have raised a question that I would like to comment on a little further, and that is the place of appraisal and valuation in this forum. Appraisal has two meanings. It can mean to assess quality, or it can mean to assess value. In the case of an assessment of quality that is one of the reasons for the existence of this forum. It is often a bit difficult to assess quality of a keris from photos, and speaking for myself, I often find that when I look at photos of a keris I am filling in details that are not clear from the photos , by reference to my knowledge of that type of keris or workmanship. This is a very defective way of giving an appraisal, but its the best we can do from photos, and I will usually add the caveat of " based upon what I think I can see in these photos". But when we come to the assessment of value, the difficulties multiply many, many times. Value is directly related to the price that is placed upon an object. It doesn't mean precisely the same thing as price, but when you get right down to it an appraisal of value is an answer to the question :- "how much should I pay ( or ask) for this object?" This answer depends upon a multitude of factors which can be split into specific segments, for example:- rareity, state of preservation, age, type, quality of workmanship, present geographical location, market bouyancy---etc, etc, etc. In respect of a keris many of the factors within the segments relating to the physical qualities of a keris can only be adequately addressed if we have the keris in hand. An error made in assessment of age or origin of any component part of a keris could have a massive impact upon the value, and thus the price that can be reasonably paid for the keris. This might not matter much when we are talking about keris that are worth only a few hundred dollars, but when we start to look at higher level pieces an error in appraisal can result in a considerable loss to the seller (or buyer). Geographic location of a keris is another important factor in affixing an estimate of a reasonable price. Lets say I see an absolutely wonderful piece advertised by a UK dealer. As a collector I want that piece, and because of where it is I know that I cannot bargain for the same price as I would if I were in a street market in Indonesia. So I am prepared to pay what I consider to be a reasonable price from a UK dealer. This would be a totally unreasonable price in almost any other place on the planet, but because of where it is I need to adapt my standards, depending on how much I want it. So if somebody asks how much something is worth, it really comes down to how much the buyer is prepared to pay, and that will vary according to circumstances, one of the circumstances being the location of the object. As an extreme example of the application of this philosophy to collecting, I know one collector of keris and other weaponry who only buys from Ebay. He's got a massive collection. He uses sniping software and puts in an extremely low bid on everything that takes his fancy. Most of his bids fail, but when he wins he buys very, very cheap. I won't comment on the quality of his collection, but it is very, very big. And the thing is this:- this man has never paid a single penny more than he was prepared to pay for any item in his collection. So, for me, appraisal of value, when that appraisal is based on photos, and most particularly when the appraisal is published for all the world to see is something that I simply would not do. It could damage my reputation immeasurably. But giving opinions to friends by private email is a completely different matter. Rick :- Re your proposals:- 1)--- agree 2)--- agree in principle, but I would prefer a longer wait period, perhaps 3 months 3)--- agree David:- I believe that your comments should have clarified any question as to the purpose of this Keris Warung Kopi, and I cannot disagree with anything that you have said. I think we might be getting somewhere with this matter. Maybe it has already been settled, but before we set anything in concrete, could we wait a little while to give others who may have a point to make a chance to provide their opinions? |
23rd November 2009, 12:06 AM | #14 |
Vikingsword Staff
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 6,267
|
Absolutely , I would like to hear from everyone .
|
23rd November 2009, 12:10 AM | #15 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,201
|
About point one:
my thought is, if there are unethical dealers, there must be also unethical buyers. There is a saying: every human has his price, and these prices are different. Other thing is, to be a policeman is not good for every character (even to be a teacher is not good for every character). About point two: Since Alan has experience with this subject, keris dealing, so I think his proposal (three months) is to be taken in earnest. It is a big difference. (For me it is clear, there absolutely cannot be discussions about direct material value or appraisals. ) |
23rd November 2009, 12:29 AM | #16 |
Member
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 6,736
|
Asomotif, I really do like that "active member" suggestion.
Really. The swap facility in this site is something very valuable for non-dealers, as I see it. In fact, I don't like the idea of anybody who is a dealer on any level being involved in it at all. A while back I gave lengthy consideration to using this swap facility myself, but I decided that for me as an experienced dealer to contribute to the forum discussions, and at the same time offer things in the Swap Forum was much too close to being a conflict of interest situation, thus I have never placed any articles for sale in that Forum, and I think only once did I place a link there to my site. I would like to see the Swap Forum kept solely for the use of collectors, and those of us who are dealers on any level, either a hobby dealer as in my case, or a full-time professional dealer as in some other cases, stay out of it, and let the pure collectors trade between themselves. The "active member" rule might not be exactly what I would like, but it would go a long way towards cleaning up the content of the Swap Forum. |
23rd November 2009, 03:27 AM | #17 | |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Witness Protection Program
Posts: 1,730
|
Quote:
this should apply to other areas as well... |
|
|
|