Wootz sharpening

[ALEX]

Originally Posted by ariel

Is the presence of such a pre-formed edge a reliable sign of wootz material?

Agree with Laurie. I do not think that the edge is a reliable wootz indicator. The same is for a fold line, which can be observed on the top edge of many wootz blades, or sound the blade makes when topped against a floor, or flexibility test, markings etc... In my opinion - the only reliable sign of wootz is the wootz pattern. Any other opinions?

[S.Al-Anizi]

Ive seen wootz blades that have only been sharpened at the COP, other areas of the blade were left dull, although they appeared to be sharp.

[mross]

Originally Posted by ALEX

Agree with Laurie. I do not think that the edge is a reliable wootz indicator. The same is for a fold line, which can be observed on the top edge of many wootz blades, or sound the blade makes when topped against a floor, or flexibility test, markings etc... In my opinion - the only reliable sign of wootz is the wootz pattern. Any other opinions?

Nope, the pattern is pretty much the acid test. (pun intended) I believe those well versed in wootz can determine age and point of origin of the steel from the pattern.