Quote:
As I've previously noted, this example is no masterpiece, but, IMHO, it's not any closer to the common "souvenir" tradition than it is to KBA 12. 
I've further reduced the comparison photo, so it would upload. The head on the comparison Naga Sasra is better than most, more like a Doberman than a mastiff, but the quality of the rendition of Semar on the handle suggests that the carver was not a superstitious person.
|
Well, hilts (and mendak) of less than stellar quality can be found all over the place.
If we concentrate on the blade, I'm afraid I don't see that much of a difference between those 2 kamardikan pieces - maybe a close-up is needed, too.
If anything, the proportions and placement of the figural carving seem to suggest somewhat better craftsmanship in the other piece...
Regards,
Kai