Quote:
|
Originally Posted by mahratt
Again, you're right. Thank you for the interesting article. But I am interested to know whether there is a direct mention to the fact that wootz steel production ceased in those years, the 19th century. Stating the reasons  |
According to old sources in most cases wootz was either hard and brittle or soft and easily to bend (Egerton, Oriental arms and armour).
I know that just a few wootz blades from Persia and maybe the Ottoman empire, were able reach the european toughness and they were extremely valuable.
I would say, this is the main reason, european steel was much cheaper and had better characteristics from technical point of view.
I am also convinced, that a top quality wootz sword (Assad Allah for example) is more difficult to forge, than a top class japanese katana (Hizen Kuni Mutsu no kami Tadayoshi quality).
The industrial production of european crucible steel begun in the middle of the 19th century.
In my opinion Indian wootz is a good steel for daggers but unsuitable for swords and sabers.
In all times, a good blacksmith was always very expensive, whether in India, Japan or Europe, everywhere.
Roland