Quote:
|
Originally Posted by estcrh
Alex, according to who?
|
about every knowledgeable collector i know, and all decent books I read.
They all could be wrong, of course. Please substantiate your argument.
By the way, in Oriental Arms sample above, it states "shamshir blade in Turkish fittings". The Kilij/Shamshir title may refer to "Kilij" as a word for sword in Turkish language, as in other similar descriptions. but I have not seen anything saying any blade with pistol grip is a Kilij.
We had similar argument before about "Saif" as any sword with Arab hilt
Word Saif means sword in Arabic, just as Kilij is sword in Turkish. What this has to do with the hilt type?