I think at least the following two aspects of the hilt are unusual:-
Why are there two fighting herons? A falcon taking down a heron is a common motif on Persian and Persian influenced swords, along with a lion taking down an antelope or bull. The symbolism is obvious, representing the ability of the owner or his loyalties to overcome his inferiors. I wonder did the maker of this hilt understand this?
Are the herons the right way up? I would say that on 99%, if not 100%, of examples or pictures I have seen motifs and inscriptions on the quillon block are designed to be viewed with the blade down. Presumably this is because the quillon block can be seen when the sword is slung and would look somewhat silly if the motif etc. was upside down. It is of course possible the motif on the outside could be the "correct" way up to be viewed when worn whilst, on the inside, the other way up, to be viewed by the drawer of the sword. If both are the wrong way up I would again wonder whether or not the maker really understood what he was doing.
It would be interesting to read other opinions.
Regards
Richard
|