Hello Alan,
Quote:
. What is the name of the hook/ thorn on top of the ron dha nunut, is it included in the ron dha nunut or not?
according to what I have been taught this is a ri pandan, and it forms part of the ron dha
|
It also was my understanding that the uppermost hook of the ron dha nunut is called ri pandan and apparently forms an integral part. However, in strict sense it does not "participate" in building the ron dha nunut while the second ri pandan forms the right hand side of ron dha nunut (as well as in the ron dha following on the gonjo).
At least from a pattern recognition approach it does make sense to call the right hand element of the ron dha motif ri pandan.
Thingil certainly suits the middle "thorn" of the ron dha motif.
Thus, the question remains what do we call the left hand structure of the ron dha motif? With its more erect and often slender structure without much curvature and those notches on its top, it seems to deserve a name of its own! Early versions seem to exhibit a bit more curvature but it seems like a stretch to me to also call this element ri pandan, too...
Quote:
. Whenever the greneng is limited to a single protrusion like for dhapur Tilam Sari, it is called thingil.
sorry Jean, not according to the Surakarta Pakem, here it is called a ri pandan
|
I also just stumbled over this paradox and am glad there is another approach. While this isolated element certainly protrudes from the general outline of the blade/gonjo, it certainly has the shape of a ri pandan!
Quote:
|
I'm in the process right now of putting up some posts that I do not expect will lessen this confusion, but will at least help you to understand what you are facing when you try to understand the keris from a Javanese perspective.
|
Great, I'm looking forward to more insights!
Regards,
Kai