Quote:
|
Originally Posted by fernando
Go figure ...
The following is an email received from my acquainted Señor Juan L. Calvó:
Estimado Señor Viana,
Celebro tener noticias suyas. Los machetes de su interés, tengo entendido son dominicanos, propios de la etnia de la Isla de Santo Domingo. Esto me fue informado con posterioridad a la clausura del Museo, por lo que en su ficha me limite a anotar el origen apuntado por el coleccionista que cedió estas piezas,
Reciba un afectuoso saludo
Juan L. Calvó
Which in a rough translation we can read:
Those machetes in which you show interest are, as i have understood, ethnically Dominican, from the Santo Domingo island. This was informed after the museum closure, for i simply made note of such origin in their records, after being enlightened by the collector who has ceded these pieces (to the museum).
I realize this later information would have taken place during conversations had with the owning collector, when the Barcelona municipality decided to close the museum (2009) and requested them to withdraw their property.
Time we compare those examples from Barcelona examples to the one originally posted by Mahratt ... just saying  .
. |
Thank you Fernando,
So now the Montjuic examples have been confirmed to be Dominican as well. Personally, based on the factual evidence we have, for me these swords are Dominican. Others can make their own conclusions, my goal is to find what I believe is true for myself, not convince anyone in anything.
Kubur,
I see a nice silver hilted machete with a red stone. I am not sure I see clear parallels with North African rifle decoration, but am willing to look at a side by side comparison. Complex decorative motives are usually a better indicator than material used, and I do not see any particular decorative motif that can provide a good clue as to where the silver decoration was applied.
Regards,
Teodor