Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Norman McCormick
Hi John,
My apologies but I have my serious doubts as to the authenticity of your Khyber knife with regard to its age. ...snip... It probably does come from India but not I think from the first half of the 19thC.
|
Hi John and Norman
I will try to adjust it a bit, this first comment
ref. to A.C. Tirri in his book "Islamic Weapons"
most of "khyber knifes (to don't said ... all) recorded in his book, are declared 19th century
the Khyber knife displayed by John seems similar, at least by the blade, the handle, it's an other matter
I have read the following comments;
- grip are usually made of horn, bone, ivory
- blades of the better specimens are made of wootz steel
- some early versions have a slightly recurved blade
the handle from John's knife, doesn't match with general description
now where I'm backing my friend Norman, it's about "authenticity"
- unique antique Afghan Indo-Persian sword
(as far as, they are hand made, all are "UNIQUE") 
- surely this must have belonged to a chief or tribal leader (
absolute extrapolation , without a beginning of prove)
- possibly an executionner's sword ?
(pure phantasm)
in short, just sales pitches without any technical merit and without valid references
all the best
à +
Dom