Atlantia,
Quote:
|
But you continued the personal nature of the disagreement with Jonathan right from the start
|
Exactly where at the beginning was it personnel? I asked Spiral in Person because it was his quote, which was used out of context to prove a point, ie something that applied to non Gurkha units up to 1881, when he clearly quotes it as linked to Gurkhas in WW1!
Also on several occasions before I started the new thread Atlantia, I gave Spiral the option to scan and post from Huxford's book on POST 13;
Quote:
|
ME; A very rare book, which seems to be your main source, as you have posted scanned pictures of the text you refer to in other books in the past, could you do the same again Jonathan?
|
As for Berkley it was in my view biased, hence I edited the post and put in his details and connection to Spiral on IKRHS, if it was not biased why did he not question Spiral about his misleading quotes, and infact one complete misquote?
A forum can only be the Mecca of something, if the information given as fact is correct! Of course a view at one time, may not be a view in the future, more than acceptable.
As for me making an apology to Thinredline, that is between myself and him, cheers Simon
PS if you want to start another independent thread that is fine by me.