Zulfikar sold on ebay?

[Sikh_soldier]

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=120205525113&ssPageName=STRK:MEWA:IT&ih=002

I read on this forum that these swords are impractical how come a senior fellow member has purchased at such a high price?
:shrug:

Not a good example for us young'uns :D ..........or is it?

[dennee]

I think that most of us would be buying few swords if only for their practicality (there is, however, practicality in a good profit)! As for practicality once upon a time, many historical weapon forms are impractical, or at least not as efficient as they might be, for a variety of reasons. Some of these, as early examples, are quite valuable--at least to Artzi!! But that does not convey significance upon the modern reproductions.

[Sikh_soldier]

Thank you Dennee,

That makes a lot of sense, I had been previously put off in the past due to the criticism of such pieces, whilst all along I do love these type of pieces for their Audacious and flamboyant design. :D

I had just thought that although nice to look at they were not a good investment.

[Jim McDougall]

Swords of this form would be considered relatively scarce, and though not 'practical' from the usual combat use perspective, have obvious profound cultural and traditional significance. The weapon is quite well described, contrary to the flights of fancy often seen in auction descriptions, and if Artzi took it at this price I think we can be confident it is worth at least that amount if not more.

Best regards,
Jim

[Emanuel]

It may be impractical, but it's a beauty and a wootz beauty at that. I noticed that the market price of wootz blades has gone up in the past year. I'm thinking folks look to the collector's amrket for sound/safe investment.

Regards,
Emanuel

[Jim McDougall]

It may be impractical, but it's a beauty and a wootz beauty at that. I noticed that the market price of wootz blades has gone up in the past year. I'm thinking folks look to the collector's amrket for sound/safe investment.

Regards,
Emanuel

The way the stock market and economy has been looking here in the U.S. lately...absolutely! :)

[ALEX]

Many beautiful and prized swords are "impractical" and made for ceremonial, religious, art, etc purposes. This one is very nice and rare form sword, depicted in many cataloques and books. Artzi is definitely knows what he's doing! Congratulations to him.

[Sikh_soldier]

Thank you to everyone for your comments, I understand now that other factors such as symbolic, religous etc are also considered when purchasing.

I would like to make clear that I did not mean to offend the buyer,
I recognised and value his experience and expertise, and knew immediately that it must be worth the price or even more.

Its just that I am new to collecting and was trying to understand whether I should try to include such pieces in my collection, I have always liked bespoke pieces like this and indeed purchased a strange one last year although it is no where near the quality of this piece (pics added), I was going to post it on the forum but it was already being discussed everyone was highly critical of it due to its practicality (balance etc) so I saved myself the embarassement ;) and buried my head in the sand

Regards
Bally

[Pukka Bundook]

Very interesting looking piece, Bally......But don't ask me to make a scabbard for it!!!!!

Thank you for showing it!.

Richard..

[Jens Nordlunde]

The easy part is to make the scabbard, the hard part would be to get it out of the scabbard:).

[Richard Furrer]

The easy part is to make the scabbard, the hard part would be to get it out of the scabbard:).

Jens,
I disagree...the hard part is making all those little crescent cuts in the edge with a file and getting them even.:rolleyes:

Ric

[Jens Nordlunde]

Ric:p

Yes, I should have thought of that:D.

Jens

[Sikh_soldier]

Very interesting looking piece, Bally......But don't ask me to make a scabbard for it!!!!!

Thank you for showing it!.

Richard..


Hmmm, now that you mention it Richard, I may have a few pieces that would love to be worked on by a master scabbard maker! :D