View Full Version : A spanish-mexican type large bowie knife ?
Marius66
23rd October 2023, 09:06 PM
Good evening dear members,
I'd like your advice about this large knife/small machete ,
21,65 inches long ( without scabbard )
He comes with his ''small'' side knife,
looks like a xxl bowie knife with a latino american style
( I find...)
Maybe antique ?
Can you help me to fix it ?!
Kind regards
milandro
24th October 2023, 08:17 AM
it certainly has a Mexican type of look.
The eagle head pommel is a very common feature. The giveaway would be (if someone recognises it) the punch stamp which loos like ENBAT? EMBAT?
werecow
24th October 2023, 11:11 AM
Interesting how much that blade resembles a short version of a klewang.
Marius66
24th October 2023, 12:17 PM
Thank you for your messages
Milandro and Werecow !
I agree with Werecow, there is something VOC colonies in the blade shape,
hilt looks more Mexican as Milandro says...
I will receive it friday I hope,
I could send better pictures of the stamp and of the blade
Kind regards
milandro
24th October 2023, 01:52 PM
the clip point and the fuller do look similar and I have been also thinking that I had seen the pommel on some Indonesian made weapon , I think that the key to identify is in the identification of the punch stamped mark.
Please make a beter picture or ask for one
IF this is Indonesian made then it is probably Tjikeroe
if you look though this thread
http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?t=948&highlight=Tjikeroeh
You will find some similarities
Interested Party
24th October 2023, 02:10 PM
the clip point and the fuller do look similar and I have been also thinking that I had seen the pommel on some Indonesian made weapon , I think that the key to identify is in the identification of the punch stamped mark.
Shaver cool?
http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?p=282150&highlight=shaver+cool#post282150
I think Mexican may be the correct answer. A clearer picture of the stamp could help.
werecow
24th October 2023, 04:22 PM
I don't know how to date these as I focus mainly on swords, but staying in the Americas for a moment, could it have been influenced by the American adoption of the klewang during WWII perhaps?
milandro
24th October 2023, 04:49 PM
if these knives are Mexican they are most likely to be influenced by the Bowie itself .
After all James Bowie died at Alamo!
gp
24th October 2023, 08:19 PM
forget Bowie...talking Mexico... Zapata is the man
( and as we all are speculating......why not perhaps could it not be influenced by Austrian / Habsburgian cold arms...thinking of Maximilian I of Mexico )
Marius66
25th October 2023, 07:01 PM
Hello everybody,
The Indonesian with Dutch influence clue seems the right one ,
Here are the other pictures I received,
I can read TIJBAT,
TIJ for Tijkeroe as proposed by Milandro ?
Marius66
25th October 2023, 08:32 PM
And the bird head pommel clearly looks like the Batavian model linked , thank you !
A garuda head ?!!
Marius66
26th October 2023, 04:55 AM
For comparison,
I found this ''similar'' one , the central piece , in another old post about klewangs/kalewangs and the regulation models
francantolin
26th October 2023, 08:07 AM
Hello,
TJIBAT simply for TJIBATOE... 😁
milandro
26th October 2023, 08:16 AM
thanks to the better pictures and the detective work on Tjbatoe look very conclusive to me.:cool:
Marius66
26th October 2023, 09:25 AM
Thank you ! Really precise !!
What can we say about the age ??
milandro
26th October 2023, 02:01 PM
Thank you ! Really precise !!
What can we say about the age ??
I don't know that anybody can say precisely but a great number of these Indonesian made weapons came in the '50 of last century
Marius66
27th October 2023, 02:08 PM
Hello,
I finally received it,
Here some pictures, an heavy model, 800 gramms
/ 1,75 pounds just for the small sword/machete .
For the dates , I read that these ''VOC dutch models'' were made until 1920 but sure, it looks more something WW2
( reminds me Aldo Raine's bowie knife in the movie Unglourious bastards... )
The steel is good
Marius66
27th October 2023, 02:12 PM
I wonder if the handle is more bone, ivory or any celluloid...
One side cracked when I cleaned it with just a little water/soap
milandro
28th October 2023, 08:16 AM
the VOC no longer existed by this time and this is certainly not inspired to the time it existed, this type of knives made there always had bone hilts
Jim McDougall
28th October 2023, 06:19 PM
This interesting sword is of course IMO, a machete, and while the only thing about it that brings to mind the famed Bowie knife, is the distinct clipped point. The Bowie knife, became a prototype for heavy bladed knives across American frontiers through the 19th c. and naturally had profound influences on Mexican knives of these types. Naturally it was the presumed knife form that was the influence, not Jim Bowie himself.
There is not a real consensus on what the original 'Bowie' knife looked like, but later versions created the form we are most familiar with, having clipped point false edge blade, various hand guards etc.
I think the Indonesian potential for this weapon, as proposed, is most compelling, despite the distinctly Mexican looking hilt, and TJIKEROE is the most plausible explanation for the abbreviated letters at the forte. As shown, the blade has distinct characteristics of the Dutch 'klewang', the military versions as 'cutlasses' used well into the 20th c.
Note the blocked forte and the distinct fuller.
As noted, the Dutch VOC was defunct in 1799, and the British controlled Dutch regions until 1814. Dutch trade of course continued and there was strong commemorative posture regarding the long standing presence of the VOC (Shaver Kool :))
Adding to speculation already in place, there is always the possible cross diffusion of a Dutch blade in Mexican hilt through the ever present complexity of trade, particularly in Philippines with the clearly strong Spanish presence.
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.