View Full Version : [Identification] Axe or Knife?
fireiceviper
29th June 2015, 11:29 PM
Can anyone identify the origin of this weapon? purchased here in the Netherlands. It looks Asian to me and others I've shown it too but still can't figure out what culture, or anything actually... :confused:
It came from a dutch museum, who labeled it "african ?" when they acquired it as a gift from missionaries.
Any help would be appreciated!
fireiceviper
30th June 2015, 04:37 PM
yesterday i contacted Mr. Burgess from www.billhooks.co.uk after a comment (on facebook ) that it could be a pruning knive. He contacted me today with the following link
Volkenkune Leiden (http://www.volkenkunde.nl/collections/record.aspx?so=H4sIAAAAAAAEAO29B2AcSZYlJi9tynt_SvV K1-B0oQiAYBMk2JBAEOzBiM3mkuwdaUcjKasqgcplVmVdZhZAzO2d vPfee--999577733ujudTif33_8_XGZkAWz2zkrayZ4hgKrIHz9-fB8_In6NX_PX-DV-jf-bHvzE8xv9WvTPt49Xq9__pJrl42p2_nZy1VSj9Cfzuimq5Wc7Y _5vlJ6sy3Zd558t83VbZ-UofbmelMX098qv31Rv8-Vny3VZ_roA-xu9zrN6Ov9y8tP5tP2t6IPf8Pdv-JM3eb34jX__dVMsL-TL5jeUv55U1dvmN5Hfj6lhcZmbr77IZ0WmLz0tLorVevKby18n VVkSDMKx-fV-__OibtrfSPt5VuTl7Nf9_S-L_Oo3_v1XdX5ZVOsGf_26v39T1e2vr81-89-_rVaf59VFnZ0X-Qsa_m-KT3ic69r-_Wy9pF74-98Efwvq8ue0WqzK_J0M-Df8_dt53sjvvxF9ZdEztP41fx16fk16fu1f-9f-Nfn5DX7Ls2Wb18usbD75SULwzfUqbzAjQ5__Vu7z1zSUL-sZTVP3CyE2vYIv_pBf8_V10-aLsUev8ef5Mq-L6fh50bR_wO73vnfij0MGOEq_Kab4_vdvhcPrAji8IRJm63rdg MDfJA5_4C1QcN998zTAXPx6vzb98-u8Xc8KTD79is_wz6_5rV_3V5NQxmYdzPPrX2blOv_9f_9f4zcA FPz_1_zfqfmvVjn-dX8V_RLljP7LeH7d_63T3jJMvP2v92P4-Muf_GJ8fHz86yXujye_3m_o_jj59X4j98fnP_Yb0x8_9pvgn98 Ug8aft2KDn2VWxAz8er9_QVg0pA2KH-S_we9_KZBoHn7rSOff45n7DX6DH_vNlBp4fh0M7FbD-Vnm6s3DiXRuh_Ob-8PBFP1cC8jGofwW3Z7tOH4Lbxy__m-Gf426_XV-y8h04q1f_zcPm0XIxM1-i6DZb9ZFAW1-w_8HWh5dcFEHAAA1)
So its solved! also someone showed me a topic on this very forum!
http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?t=2905
VANDOO
30th June 2015, 07:36 PM
I HAVE SOMETHING SIMULAR THAT I HAD POSTED IN THE NAGA POST IN THE FORUM. IT LOOKS MUCH LIKE THESE EXAMPLES BUT IS MORE CRUDELY MADE.
HERE IS A PICTURE OF MY ITEM FOR COMPARASON.
Oriental-Arms
30th June 2015, 08:11 PM
Another exemplar
Mr. Philip Hartmann from the Netherlands suggested me that it is a chopper from Bali- Indonesia used in burial ceremonies
A. G. Maisey
30th June 2015, 11:49 PM
The item shown in post #1 is Javanese. I'm uncertain of exactly where in Jawa, I'm inclined to think Central Jawa, but it could equally be either North Coast or East Jawa. I do not think it is from Madura.
It could be called a kudi, a bendho or a lukeh, depending on who was doing the naming.
Sajen
30th June 2015, 11:58 PM
The item shown in post #1 is Javanese. I'm uncertain of exactly where in Jawa, I'm inclined to think Central Jawa, but it could equally be either North Coast or East Jawa. I do not think it is from Madura.
It could be called a kudi, a bendho or a lukeh, depending on who was doing the naming.
Hello Alan,
do you know if it was used as weapon, agricultural tool or as ceremonial knife?
Regards,
Detlef
A. G. Maisey
1st July 2015, 02:46 AM
The one shown seems to be far too good a quality to be a tool.
In the Radyapustaka Museum in Solo there are more than a few examples of things that we think of as tools now, but which were clearly weapons in the past. Javanese society is a rural society, and a lot of Javanese weapons have a tool form.
I think we can forget ceremonial use.
Sajen
1st July 2015, 07:19 AM
Thank you for your educated statement.
Regards,
Detlef
fireiceviper
13th July 2015, 11:12 PM
The ones in the volkenkunde museum are all labeled "kapmes" though which roughly translates to "machete".
But i also agree its a lot of work for a simple machete...
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.