Log in

View Full Version : Can someone identify this sword Viking ?


bguevremont
26th September 2005, 05:59 PM
This sword has a solid silver handle and bronze blade
no other maker marks seen but a nice detail on the handle .
picture provided ... is it Viking ,Roman ???

Tim Simmons
26th September 2005, 06:29 PM
Hello, I do not think this is ancient or European. I personally think you should be looking towards Indo/Persia. I could be wrong. Tim

Tim Simmons
26th September 2005, 06:46 PM
If it was European, it looks pre Roman and if it is yours then you would have the most exceptional collection a little beyond interest in this site. If it was Celtic it would make world news :D . Tim

fearn
26th September 2005, 07:19 PM
Showing the rest of the blade and describing a little bit more about it would be useful (how long you've had it, etc). I'm skeptical that it's Celtic, but beyond that, I can't tell. Given the good condition of the silver and the interesting condition of the bronze, something's definitely weird about this one, and it's not just the design. Silver corrodes at least as fast as bronze does.

F

Ahriman
26th September 2005, 10:17 PM
Viking out, they used quite different hilt parts, and preferred much shorter hilts. Especially the pommel seems out of place for anything viking.
Roman out as well as far as I know, as they used more rounded hilts, with almost-spherical wooden pommels.
Celtic... I'm not sure, they never used much armour so I don't know much about them :D , but I think they almost always used antropomorphic hilts.
The quillon seems VERY indian to me.
Hm, not much info, sorry...

Oh, almost forgot: that "tongue" part of the quillon is quite out of western europe as well... I've never seen anything like this on western swords except the claymore, but that would've been recognised by a glance. :)

Justin
26th September 2005, 11:56 PM
I personally haven't read about any Celtic bronze swords with hilts like this,they are either integral to the blade and solid,or flat tangs made to have scales riveted on,but I am far from an expert.

ham
27th September 2005, 12:14 AM
The hilt is 16th century Mughal type, though not necessarily that old. With a bronze blade, it may well be a married piece.

Ham

Jim McDougall
27th September 2005, 02:22 AM
Without further research I am inclined to agree with Ham on this, and think Tim is correct as well in suggesting the Indian subcontinent, very likely the southern regions. The style of the hilt and the bronze blade suggest this is likely a votive or ceremonial piece, and as Ham notes, not necessarily as old as the style suggests and not necessarily homegenous.
Best regards,
Jim